Robert Lerner - The Heresy of the Free Spirit in the Later Middle Ages

Click for larger version Robert Lerner - The Heresy of the Free Spirit in the Later Middle Ages
[University of Notre Dame Press]

The heresy of the Free Spirit is often considered to have been the most important continental European heresy of the fourteenth century. Many historians have described its membership as a league of anarchist deviants who fomented sexual license and subversion of authority. Free spirits are supposed to have justified nihilism and megalomania and to have been remote precursors of Bakunin and Nietzsche and twentieth century bohemians and hippies. This volume examines the Free Spirit movement as it appeared in its own age, and concludes that it was not a tightly-organized sect but rather a spectrum of belief that emphasized voluntary poverty and quietistic mysticism. Overall, the movement was far more typical of the late-medieval search for God and godliness than is commonly supposed.

Contents
Acknowledgements
Abbreviations
Introduction
Heresy and Fornication
1 Three Racy Stories
2 The Heresy in the Swabian Ries
3 Heresy and Fornication: a Topos of the Thirteenth Century
4 Adamites and Luciferans in the Fourteenth Centruy
Beghards and Beguines
1 Origins and Sources of Hostility
2 The Heresy of Lay Piety
3 Conrad of Megenberg and John Wasmod of Homburg
The Condemnation
1 The Thirteenth Century
2 The German Decrees
3 Marguerite Porete
4 The Council of Vienne
The Inquisition in Strassburg
1 The Campaign of John of Zürich
2 The Second Wave of Persecutions
3 The Case of John Malkaw
4 The Third Wave of Persecutions
The Inquisition in the East
1 John and Albert of Brünne
2 The Beguines of Schweidnitz
3 The Hussite Problem
The Inquisition in the West
1 Hermann Kuchener and Constantine of Erfurt
2 The Revival of the Papal Inquisition
3 The Campaign of Walter Kerlinger: John Hartmann and the Beguines of Thuringia
4 Conrad Kannler
5 The Campaigns of Martin of Prague, Peter Zwicker, and Eylard Schoenveld
6 Nicholas of Basel and the Campaign of John Mulberg
7 The "Men of Intelligence"
The Fifteenth Century
1 The Polemics of Gerson
2 The Era of the Council of Basel
3 Hans Becker
The Predicament of the Mystics
1 Meister Eckhart
2 Eckhart's Orthodox Followers
3 Ruysbroeck
4 Groote and the Brethren of the Common Life
The Literature of the Free Spirit
1 The Mirror of Simple Souls
2 The Pseudo-Eckhart Literature
3 De onbekende leek and Schwester Katrei
4 The Rhineland libelli and The Book of Spiritual Poverty
5 Conclusions
The Place of the Heresy of the Free Spirit in Social and Cultural History
1 Who Were the Free Spirits?
2 Motivation
3 "The Pursuit of the Millennium" or "Beyond Good and Evil"?
4 The Lay Spirit and the Dignity of Man
5 Ultimate Failure
List of manuscripts
Index

 

One Response to “Robert Lerner - The Heresy of the Free Spirit in the Later Middle Ages”

  1. rab Says:

    The work of an historian/scholar rather than an historian/writer, so it is rather dry. Interesting, nevertheless, as there are few other books on the topic. A succession of facts where the reader must make the effort towards coherency. The author seems to have an axe to grind against Norman Cohn's The Pursuit of the Millenium and its interpretation of the Free Spirits, certainly Cohn is the better writer of the two.

    Many notes are just quotes in the original German - the author seems to think we must be able to read German, although admits to knowing no Czech himself and, by that, ignoring such source material.

    The author's main agenda seems to be to refute the 'rash of journalistic attempts to compare [the Free Spirits] to rebellious university students and hippies'. I think he misses the point.

    Surprising, and possibly even irritating, is the abrupt manner in which the author justifies closing his chronological account at the end of the seventh chapter. He says, 'It was the custom of German universities to break the monotony of official ceremonies by staging a mock lecture of grotesque erudtion for the purposes of entertainment. In Heidelberg in the late summer of 1458, and unnamed master … comically held forth about beghards', and, all of a sudden declares, 'With this clear recognition of the subject as a joke we may end our chronolgical survey, having shown that there was no organised sect of the Free Spirit to have influenced the Reformation.'

    Chapter 9, 'The Literature of the Free Spirit', just left me wanting less of the author's opinions on the works and reprints of the works themselves.

    Using Galeon Galeon 2.0.0 on Debian GNU/Linux Debian GNU/Linux

Leave a Comment

  • You are currently browsing the Robert Lerner - The Heresy of the Free Spirit in the Later Middle Ages entry of the breviary stuff

  • Current Books

    Further information and comments (RSS)
    Raoul Vaneigem - The Movement of the Free Spirit, General Considerations and Firsthand Testimony Concerning Some Brief Flowerings of Life in the Middle Ages, the Renaissance and, Incidentally, Our Own Time Raoul Vaneigem - The Movement of the Free Spirit, General Considerations and Firsthand Testimony Concerning Some Brief Flowerings of Life in the Middle Ages, the Renaissance and, Incidentally, Our Own Time
    [Zone Books 1994]
    Douglas Hay, Peter Linebaugh, John G. Rule, E. P. Thompson, and Cal Winslow - Albion's Fatal Tree, Crime and Society in Eighteenth-Century England Douglas Hay, Peter Linebaugh, John G. Rule, E. P. Thompson, and Cal Winslow - Albion's Fatal Tree, Crime and Society in Eighteenth-Century England
    [Pantheon 1975]
    Frank Aydelotte - Elizabethan Rogues and Vagabonds Frank Aydelotte - Elizabethan Rogues and Vagabonds
    [Frank Cass 1967]
    Marcus Rediker - Villains of All Nations, Atlantic Pirates in the Golden Age Marcus Rediker - Villains of All Nations, Atlantic Pirates in the Golden Age
    [Verso 2004]
  • Current Music

    Henry Snowstorm - Civil Unrest Henry Snowstorm - Civil Unrest
    [the Wild Beast Records 2007]
    Karl Hector and The Malcouns - Sahara Swing Karl Hector & The Malcouns - Sahara Swing
    [Now-Again 2008]
    Nigeria Special: Modern Highlife, Afro Sounds and Nigerian Blues 1970-6 Nigeria Special: Modern Highlife, Afro Sounds and Nigerian Blues 1970-6
    [Soundway Records 2008]
    Hypnotic Brass Ensemble - Sankofa / Salah Ragab - One Tree/Ole Hypnotic Brass Ensemble - Sankofa / Salah Ragab and the Afro-Egyptian Ensemble - One Tree/Ole
    [Honest Jon's Records 2007]
    Hypnotic Brass Ensemble - Brass In Africa Hypnotic Brass Ensemble - Brass In Africa
    [Handcuts Records 2007]
  • Latest from Atlas Press

    Carlo Emilio Gadda - The Philosophers' Madonna Carlo Emilio Gadda - The Philosophers' Madonna
    [Eclectics & Heteroclites 8 2008]
    Alfred Jarry - Three Early Novels Alfred Jarry - Three Early Novels
    [Anti Classic 9 2007]
    Michel Leiris - Mirror of Tauromachy Michel Leiris - Mirror of Tauromachy
    [Eclectics & Heteroclites 7 2007]
    Konrad Bayer - the sixth sense Konrad Bayer - the sixth sense
    [Eclectics & Heteroclites 6 2007]
  • Pages

  • Categories

  • Archives